Hoka Challenger 7 VS Speedgoat 5: What Should I Buy?

The Hoka One One Challenger 7 and Speedgoat 5 are both popular trail running shoes from Hoka One One. However, they are designed for slightly different purposes.

The Challenger 7 is best for moderate trails and all-around training, while the Speedgoat 5 is ideal for technical terrain and ultramarathon distances. This in-depth comparison will highlight the key similarities and differences to help you choose which model is better for your needs.

Similarities And Differences Between Hoka Challenger 7 and Speedgoat 5:

FeatureChallenger 7Speedgoat 5
Launched In20232022
StabilityModerateModerate
FlexibilityModerateModerate
SizingMen’s 7-13, Women’s 5-11Men’s 7-13, Women’s 5-11
Weight9.3 oz (men’s)10.76 oz (men’s)
CushionHighMaximal
OutsoleVibram® Megagrip with 5mm lugsVibram® Megagrip with 5mm lugs
MidsolePROFLYTM dual-density foamCMEVA foam
UpperEngineered meshDouble-layer engineered mesh
Retail Price$145$155

Features Comparison

Materials

The Challenger 7 uses an engineered mesh upper with minimal layers for breathability. The Speedgoat 5 has a double-layer engineered mesh upper for added durability and protection.

CHALLENGER 7
CHALLENGER 7

SPEEDGOAT 5
SPEEDGOAT 5

Both shoes use Vibram® Megagrip rubber in the outsole for traction, but they differ in the midsole foam. The Challenger 7 uses PROFLYTM dual-density foam while the Speedgoat 5 uses CMEVA foam for maximum cushioning.

Durability

The Challenger 7 is built to last for around 300-500 miles. The engineered mesh upper is fairly durable, and the Vibram® outsole rubber provides good wear resistance.

The Speedgoat 5 has excellent durability with a double-layer upper and Vibram® outsole. It can withstand 500+ miles of wear and tear. The Speedgoat 5 edges out the Challenger 7 when it comes to longevity.

Fit

The Challenger 7 runs true to size for most runners and has a more customizable, secure fit from the flat laces and inner sleeve construction.

CHALLENGER 7 TOP VIEW
CHALLENGER 7 TOP VIEW

SPEEDGOAT 5 TOP VIEW
SPEEDGOAT 5 TOP VIEW

The Speedgoat 5 also runs true to size but some find it has a wider fit, especially in the toe box area. The Speedgoat 5 may not work as well for runners with narrow feet. Overall, the Challenger 7 accommodates more foot shapes.

Stability

Both shoes provide moderate stability without being overly controlling. The Challenger 7 gets some stability from the slightly wider base, foam sidewalls, and medial post.

The Speedgoat 5 relies on the flat base and upper construction to provide a stable platform without posting. For those needing some pronation control, the Challenger 7 is the better option.

Cushioning

The Speedgoat 5 has thicker, plusher cushioning than the Challenger 7. The CMEVA foam midsole gives it a soft, cushioned ride that works well for ultramarathons.

The Challenger 7 has a moderately cushioned PROFLYTM foam that balances support and responsiveness. For maximum cushioning, the Speedgoat 5 is superior. But the Challenger 7 still provides plenty of cushion for long runs.

Value

At $155, the Speedgoat 5 costs around $10 more than the Challenger 7. Both deliver excellent value with long-lasting construction and comfortable cushioning systems.

The Speedgoat 5 justifies the slightly higher price with its durable upper and thicker cushioning that performs well over ultramarathon distances. But both represent a good value for versatile trail shoes.

Performance Comparison

Walking

The Challenger 7 and Speedgoat 5 both perform well for walking, thanks to the comfortable cushioning. The Challenger 7 may work slightly better for leisurely walks.

Its moderate cushioning feels lively and responsive at walking paces, while also providing protection underfoot. The Speedgoat 5 feels overly cushioned at slower paces.

Running

For moderate trail runs, the Challenger 7 gets the edge with its balanced cushioning and secure fit. But for ultramarathon distances and technical terrain, the Speedgoat 5 is superior. Its thicker cushioning absorbs impact over many miles, and the deep lugs provide traction on varied surfaces.

Plantar Fasciitis

The Speedgoat 5 is the better choice for plantar fasciitis with its plush cushioning under the heel. The raised heel crash pad also helps absorb impact with each step. While also cushioned, the Challenger 7 may not provide enough shock attenuation for painful inflammation.

All-Day Standing

With their comfortable cushioning and moderate arch support, both models work for extended standing. The Speedgoat 5 has a slight advantage with its plusher midsole that stays resilient even after hours on your feet. But the Challenger 7 also cushions and supports well for long periods of standing.

Final Verdict

For moderate trails and all-around training, the Hoka Challenger 7 is the better pick with its secure fit, lively cushioning, and reasonable price.


But the Speedgoat 5 takes the lead for technical ultramarathons and challenging terrain thanks to its durable construction, maximum cushioning, and enhanced outsole traction.

Choose the Hoka Speedgoat 5 if you primarily run ultramarathons, long distances, or very rocky trails. For shorter to mid-range trail runs on moderate terrain, select the well-balanced Hoka Challenger 7.

Leave a comment