When it comes to choosing running shoes, there are many excellent brands to consider that offer cushioning, support, and energizing propulsion. Two stand-out companies in the market are On Cloud and Newton.
Both brands have unique technologies like CloudTec pods or Action/Reaction lugs to deliver a smooth, comfortable ride. Determining which shoe is right for you depends on factors like fit, running style, training goals, and personal preferences.
This in-depth comparison looks at critical differences between On Cloud and Newton to help find your perfect match. With insights into comfort, durability, design, price points, and performance, you can make an informed decision based on your individual needs as an athlete. Keep reading to learn which shoe might help you run stronger for miles to come.
Comparison Table
| Category | On Cloud | Newton |
|---|---|---|
| Founded In | 2010 | 2004 |
| Comfort & Fit | Soft, cloud-like cushioning. 6mm drop for natural foot positioning. | Action/Reaction lugs provide propulsion. Variable cushioning from responsive to plush. |
| Color Options | Vibrant color options across models. | More muted color palettes. Pops of color on some models. |
| Durability | Average lifespan of 300-500 miles. Rubber wears quicker than some brands. | Outsole rubber offers 500+ mile lifespan for many shoes. |
| Performance | Excellent energy return from CloudTec pods. Designed for neutral runners. | Lugs offer explosive energy return. Options for neutral and stability. |
| Design & Style | Sleek, modern aesthetic. Visible CloudTec pods are eye-catching. | Understated design. Lugs are visible but blend into outsole. |
| Popularity | Growing popularity since launch. Not as mainstream as giants like Nike or Brooks. | Small but loyal following. Less brand recognition than bigger brands. |
On Cloud Overview
Swiss running shoe brand On Running took the market by storm when they debuted their revolutionary CloudTec cushioning system in 2010.
Co-founded by Olivier Bernhard, David Allemann, and Caspar Coppetti, On Running sought to shake up the look and feel of running shoes.
Unlike the thick foam midsoles of brands like Hoka and Brooks, On shoes feature individual rubber pods strategically placed on the outsole.
This signature CloudTec cushioning provides a firm yet responsive feel. The pods compress and rebound independently to deliver what On calls a “soft landing followed by an explosive take-off.”
Most On Running shoe models also incorporate the company’s Speedboard technology, a curved plastic plate that improves transitions from heel to toe.
Together, the CloudTec sole and Speedboard reduce muscle vibration and create what On describes as a “smooth running sensation.” The outsoles are strategically mapped to match key pressure points during the phases of a runner’s stride. On Running shoes tend to have close-fitting mesh uppers to hold the foot securely.
While On Running’s CloudTec cushioning doesn’t isolate impact as much as maximally cushioned shoes, the pods respond individually to deliver energetic rebound. This makes On shoes ideal for efficient runners who want some feedback from the ground. The technology caters to midfoot and forefoot strikers with an emphasis on propelling runners forward.
Over the past decade, On Running has unveiled innovations like the CloudTec Lite system using hollowed-out pods to shed weight, and the Cloudboom midsole foam for additional underfoot softness. Their unique sole technology combined with clean, minimalist uppers gives On Running shoes an identifiable look.
Newton Running Overview
Newton Running was co-founded in 2004 by Danny Abshire and Jerry Lee Newton, both pioneers in running shoe technologies. Newton shoes feature a unique lug system called Action/Reaction technology to optimize performance.
Strategically placed lugs compress and rebound with each strike, returning energy to the runner for a propulsive sensation. This provides multi-directional cushioning while also reducing landing impact forces.
In addition, Newton shoes boast a Biomechanical Metatarsal Sensor Plate to encourage natural foot positioning and movement. Their Dynamic Engagement Midsole forms the core of the responsive cushioning system.
Newton develops shoes for all types of runners, with options for neutral pronators and moderate stability. If you’re looking for a running shoe that converts impact into forward momentum, Newton is worth considering.
Major Differences Between the Brands
Comfort and Fit
On Cloud, shoes are known for their exceptional comfort right out of the box. The soft, cloud-like CloudTec cushioning provides plush landings without sacrificing responsiveness. They offer a roomy toe box and secure midfoot wrap for a customized fit.
The moderate 6mm drop fits most foot types. Newton has dialed in their comfort too, with shoes ranging from flexible and lightweight to ultra-cushioned. However, their lug system feels unique and can take some adjustment. The snug midfoot fit of many models also doesn’t work for some.
Durability and Performance
The biggest complaints about On Cloud shoes are durability issues, with the outsoles showing wear and tear after 300-500 miles. The grippy CloudTec rubber just doesn’t last as long as brands like Newton. In terms of performance, the energetic pops from the Cloud pods give excellent rebound, making them ideal for neutral runners seeking a lively ride.
Newton shoes are built to last, with high-quality rubber outsoles that can handle 500+ miles for many models. Their dynamic lug technology also delivers on performance, providing explosive energy return stride after stride. This makes them great for neutral and stability runners who want to feel propelled.
Price
Cloud shoes have premium price tags ranging from $130 to $180 in general. Their Cloudultra model exceeds $200. Newton shoes are priced similarly, spanning $100 to $175 for most models, while top designs like the Gravity cost over $200. Ultimately, both brands are on the expensive end for serious runners investing in advanced performance features.
Design and Style
With their prominent CloudTec pods on full display, On Cloud shoes have an eye-catching, modern aesthetic. They come in vibrant color options and sleek silhouettes, making them fashionable on and off the run.
Newton shoes look more understated and blend the Action/Reaction lugs into the overall outsole design. They offer some color pops but favor toned-down palettes. For runners who value stand-out style, On Cloud is the winner.
Popularity
Since their launch in 2010, On Cloud shoes have made impressive gains in popularity and market share, though they aren’t yet on the scale of giants like Nike and Brooks.
Newton is a smaller brand with a cult following of loyal fans who swear by their lug technology and energetic ride. But they lack the widespread recognition and retailer availability of bigger brands. Between the two, On Cloud shoes have broader mainstream appeal.
Target Market
On Cloud designs its shoes primarily for neutral runners seeking lightweight performance and plush cushioning. Their Cloud line works best for easy runs through to marathon distances.
With extra stability features in some models like the Cloud X, they also appeal to mild overpronators. Newton has options for neutral and stable runners across speeds and distances. They work for various foot types seeking a responsive, propulsive ride.
Performance Comparison
How do On Cloud and Newton stack up head-to-head for specific running and training needs? Here’s a detailed breakdown:
For Nurses
With long hours on their feet, nurses need comfortable shoes that offer cushioning and support. For this purpose, On Cloud shoes are ideal to absorb shock and reduce foot fatigue. Models like the Cloud Ace provide plush landings without sacrificing grip, making them suitable for the demands of nursing.
For Walking
On Cloud, shoes have the edge for walking thanks to their easy-wearing comfort right out of the box. The CloudTec system provides responsive cushioning to handle mile after mile on the sidewalk or trail. Newton’s shoes can feel overly stiff at slower walking paces.
For Running
For traditional running gaits, On Cloud excels at providing lively energy return in a lightweight package ideal for neutral runners up to marathon distances and beyond.
Newton propels runners forward with their explosive Action/Reaction lug system that converts impact into momentum. They work best for midfoot and forefoot strikers seeking a unique responsive ride. It comes down to personal preference based on feel.
For Flat Feet
With their moderate arch support and roomy fit, On Cloud shoes work well for runners with flat feet who need cushioning and stabilization from overpronation. Models like the Cloud X provide support features while still feeling lively. Newton also offers stability options like the Stability line to provide arch support and guiding for flat feet.
For High Arches
High arches benefit from ample cushioning and flexible uppers that don’t restrict natural foot movement. On Cloud shoes deliver plush landings that runners can customize with added orthotics if needed. Newton also offers models with cushioning and roomy toe boxes, but their snug midfoot areas may not accommodate orthotics as well.
For Plantar Fasciitis
The soft cushioning and shock absorption of On Cloud shoes make them a great choice for plantar fasciitis, reducing pain and impact on affected heels and arches.
The Cloud Ultra and Cloudace are especially good options. Newton’s deep heel cups and cushioning also help absorb shock, but some models feel too rigid for plantar fasciitis.
Final Verdict
In the end, choosing between On Cloud and Newton comes down to personal fit and preferences around cushioning, stability, and propulsion. For lightweight comfort right out of the box, On Cloud is hard to beat. And their CloudTec propulsion works for a smooth, enjoyable run across speeds and distances.
Newton offers a uniquely energetic ride from their Action/Reaction lug system, but they aren’t as versatile across paces. While priced on the higher end, both brands deliver advanced performance